For a variety of reasons, I am personally not a fan of the open kitchen cupboard, despite the fact that I happen to be the proud owner of two of them. By open, I do not mean that kind of kitchen hazard that occurs when some careless trespasser has accidentally left one of the cupboard doors slightly ajar. Of course, poor unsuspecting moms usually discover this by walking straight into the corner of the offending cupboard door, which had been safely shut only a few seconds earlier. Giving yourself a big ole black eye while baking brownies for the family was probably not at the top of your daily to do list. It goes without saying that the loved one who left the door open doesn't get to enjoy any brownies fresh from the oven...at least not until they fess up to the crime and fetch mommy a bag of frozen peas to ice her aching eye socket.
The kind of open cupboard that I am referring to here is open as in open concept, total dish freedom, a doorless set of shelves where you keep all of your trusty kitchen gadgets, dishes, and glassware in plain sight. Not only does this kind of cupboard leave your dishware cruelly exposed to the elements, they are also constantly displayed for all the world to see the minute they cross the threshold of your kitchen. Unless, of course, you live in one of those trendy new-fangled homes that boasts a lovely, spacious, open floor plan...then, even the UPS guy (or lady...mine happens to be a dude, but I am savvy enough to realize that your delivery person might not be) can probably easily scope out the state of your cupboards from your front porch without ever setting foot inside your home.
The first problem with the open cupboard situation is that of all of the homemaking tasks that loom large over my entire body on a daily basis, I do not wish to add the pressure of keeping perfect cupboards to my chore list. Having the ability to shove dishes in a cupboard with a loose sense of organization without having to worry that guests will judge me based on how neatly or sloppily my dishware happens to be stacked is essential to my survival as a homemaker. No worries to all you white-gloved visitors out there, there will still be plenty left to judge about my home without exposing the inner guts of my happy, crowded little cupboards. While they may not look perfectly organized on the inside, I assure you that, for me, they are perfectly functional.
The second problem with open cupboards is the shocking amount of unsightly dirt, dust, and grime that can accumulate on both the dishes and their surrounding shelving. This is particularly problematic for those specialty items that are rarely circulated. If all of your dishes got a regular mealtime workout, then you would basically have no worries. Keeping dishes in a constant rotation will keep them regularly cleaned and shiny. However, the more problematic areas are those less used objects that you keep around for a few times a year when you decide to get a little fancy. Even when secured in a closed cupboard, you may find that your special occasion china, your special pan for baking mini donuts, or your special crystal plate for displaying deviled eggs are in need of a good scrub before you use them again. Obviously, no one wants to swill a bit of egg nog out of a lovely, yet dust-coated, holiday goblet. If dust and debris can sneakily wheedle its way deep into cupboards that are closed up tight, imagine the disaster you might find if you were to heartily embrace the open cupboard concept.
In order to properly disinfect the pretty punch bowl that you use once a year at annual holiday gatherings, you are going to have to drag it out into your yard in the middle of December. If you don't hose it off outside, you risk contaminating your poor family's lungs with unidentifiable dust particles, year-old bits of petrified household debris, and some kind of mysterious plant spores (despite the fact that you do not own a single houseplant). Somehow a thick combination of this crud has accumulated on every available surface of your punch bowl. If you attempt to handle this task indoors and one of your loved ones should inadvertently suck in a toxic dust rhino the size of Arkansas, one that has been hiding and growing deep inside the bowl since last New Year's, don't forget to pack up a plate of Christmas cookies and a thermos of eggnog to share with the nurses at the nearest local ER. I promise you will get better care if you arrive bearing baked goods even if they are snickering at you and your open cupboards behind your back. Don't worry though, they've seen this kind of thing before. Didn't you hear the admitting nurse say, "Hey Marge, the family behind curtain sixteen is a victim of the open cupboard bandwagon. We've got another classic case of acute dust bunny inhalation on our hands tonight. Treat 'em right though, they brought homemade cookies and eggnog. I'll see if anybody has a flask hidden under their scrubs in order to make things a bit more festive during tonight's shift."
I don't care what lies those interior designers on television or the helpful people at IKEA try to sell you, I am telling you that the open cupboard is a complete and total waste of time. Why you may be wondering if I am so opposed to this kitchen design disaster do I happen to have not one but TWO open cupboards in my own kitchen? I will attempt to explain this oddity. In a hasty decision that placed function over form, on one of his visits, my dad spent a single afternoon whipping up two lovely pieces of furniture for my kitchen. Their intended purpose was two-fold. To provide storage space which I desperately needed, as well as extra counter space so that I might actually be able to prepare food in my kitchen. Without them, my culinary efforts would be confined to the only available flat surface in the kitchen, (besides the vinyl tile floor, a less than appetizing choice) a two by three foot workspace to the right of the sink. I know for those of you who have lived in an efficiency apartment, these kind of kitchen accommodations might seem luxurious, but once the microwave, the toaster, and the coffee maker were in place, there was little to no room left for actual food preparation. You would have been hard-pressed to find enough available counter space to successfully open a can of Spaghetti-o's, not that I would ever in my life open a can of those, as I find them utterly revolting, but you get the point.
Seeing me struggle to chop vegetables with a cutting board balanced precariously on top of the toaster prompted my father to spring into action. After all, he preferred having a daughter with ten fingers not nine. Did I mention that this happened on the day before I hosted my very first Easter dinner at the house that "the man-friend with whom I lived" and I had recently purchased. (This was the title I used to use for my husband before we were actually married. Saying my boyfriend and being over thirty at the time always made me feel awkward like I might as well be calling him my prom date or something. There is no grown-up word to refer to this situation. Someone should invent one. I mean saying the guy I'm seeing sounds too casual and saying the guy I live with sounds too trampy. Saying my husband is a lie and if accidentally used in the wrong context people get all excited thinking you eloped in Vegas over the weekend. Then you have to explain that no, you did not in fact elope and no, he has not asked for your hand in marriage yet, and yes, you have been together for twelve whole years. Common law husband? Obviously something is wrong with one of you, otherwise you'd be officially married. Partner? Waffles between being too gay and too cowboy. See, we really need a better word for this kind of thing. By the way, Happy
When my father created the now infamous Easter Island and it's accompanying sideboard for my would-be spouse and I, his efforts were complicated by a few tricky issues unique to the design of our home. The sideboard had to be left completely open, in both the front and back, as there was a heating vent located directly behind it. Allowing unrestricted airflow was necessary to prevent the plumbing on the other side of the kitchen from freezing and exploding during the blustery February freeze while my future spouse and I were off vacationing in the Carribean. Placing an open cupboard in that particular location, the only space available, I might add, was already a calculated risk. I didn't want to tempt fate even further by hanging a little curtain up for fear of accidentally frosting over the water pipes while I was away in the dead of winter. I learned that little curtain trick from my mom of course. During a period of remodeling in my childhood home, she had open cupboards for a brief period of time. (Well, it felt brief to me, if you were to ask her, she might tell you that it was actually ten years, but who can remember?) She used shiny gold spring rods and little ruffled curtains to manage her doorless cupboard situation. Cute, clutter-hiding, dust-shielding curtains. Very innovate and resourceful idea that I absolutely love, but unfortunately not practical for my purposes. Returning from a beautiful vacation to find busted water pipes have blown water all over the interior of your home somehow makes your bliss-filled get-a-way a bit less blissful. The desire to have lovely clutter-concealing curtains grace my cupboards just wasn't worth the risk of redecorating my kitchen with an unplanned water feature.
As for our lovely Easter island, placing doors on it was a logistical nightmare due to the space contraints of my tiny elf-sized kitchen. No matter which way you tried to situate the island, there was no way that you put doors on it and still successfully open them without bashing then into the nearby shelving, the other cabinets, or the refrigerator. Even if you managed to open them without denting every other vertical surface in the room, you would have had to contort yourself into a pretzel-like position in order to extract necessary items from the interior of the island. There was no way that the doors could have ever been opened fully. This would have made storing any items over a certain circumference practically impossible, which is how we ended up simply leaving it doorless altogether. These pieces were meant to be a short term solution for a temporary problem, and at the time, it seemed like no big deal. Five years later, after a wedding and a baby, I am realizing that they may continue to be a more permanent kitchen feature than I had originally planned for a bit longer. Like until the year my son turns eighteen.
That may be the next time we actually have the extra time and resources to take on an intensive but necessary kitchen remodel. In the meantime, those crazy cupboards have become the bane of my existence. Of course, this in no way reflects on the quality of my dad's design or his solid craftsmanship. Without these two pieces of kitchen furniture, I would have no where to put any of my pots and pans, serving bowls and platters, or kitchen appliances. Also, I might be down a finger or two from trying to precariously prep carrot and celery sticks on top of the toaster. I am forever grateful for his contributions to my kitchen, especially since the original version only came with four cupboards and one drawer. This drawer is no longer in service at this time because after we replaced our vintage 1950s era stove, our sole kitchen drawer no longer opened without crashing into the handle of the new stove requiring it to be permanently sealed. The drawer of course...not the stove. I know that people have much worse kitchen difficulties. I did live in an efficiency apartment in Paris for a few years, so I am well aware of what it means to have a truly minuscule corner of the room for cooking without a single shelf to your name, not even an open one.
My utter disdain for the open cupboard was created many moons ago. It was not due to any experiences in my current home or the one of my parents. It was created and nurtured by a three-shelf monstrosity that engulfed the entire upper half of one of the wall's in my grandmother's kitchen. Once a year, usually in the spring, but sometimes in the blazing heat of summer, we would set off on a pilgrimage to my maternal grandmother's house in order to help her do
Whether it was the height of summer or the dead of winter, once you entered her home, you lost all concept of what the outdoor climate might be. We quickly learned to dress in layers in order to avoid falling victim to heat stroke in the middle of our Thanksgiving feast. My father, my siblings, and I would all fight to be the one to let the dogs in or out of the backyard. It was a cheap excuse to stick your head out the back door of the kitchen and suck in refreshing gasps of crisp November air in order to cool your core body temperature to a less life threatening level. I may or may not have feigned being woozy on occasion just so that my dad would have to take me outside and walk me around the block a few times until I came around. Oddly enough, he never complained about doing this even when he knew we were faking. In fact, he may have even encouraged our little fainting episodes by unexpectedly exclaiming things like, "Oh no! Your sister is looking peaked, I'm taking her outside for some fresh air." Funny, like the rest of us, my sister was starting to break a sweat, but she hardly looked as though she were about to pass out at any moment. He also took to reading the paper on the screened in sun porch after holiday dinners even in November and December. If you brushed the snow off the glider, it was actually quite comfortable. One year, I even borrowed some disposable elastic sweatbands from my paternal grandfather's extensive supply and placed them in everyone's stocking to be used at the Christmas dinner table in order to prevent us all from getting sweat in our eyes. Despite the fact that they were both practical and necessary, my mom recommended that we forgo the sweatbands in favor of blotting our brows with the golden cloth napkins that my grandmother used at her holiday table. We didn't want to accidentally offend Grandma after all. Of course, she was right, but I also didn't want to end up with cranberry sauce in my eye or mashed potatoes on my forehead.
While my dad sweated out every holiday meal with the rest of us, he almost never accompanied us on our annual spring cleaning adventures at Grandma's house as he always had to go to work. Besides the usual tasks that you might expect like wiping down wallpaper, scrubbing floors, and clearing out clutter, we had the additional burden of tackling the giant orphanage for wayward dishes that loomed over the entire left side of my grandmother's kitchen. After a solid year of neglect, almost every dish that was stored there, was coated in about three inches of sticky, difficult to detach, dust, grit, and grime. It was so thick that it was hard to identify whether an item that you held in your hands was a gravy boat, a beer stein, or a teapot. My uncles collected cartoon character drinking glasses, but they only kept certain select ones in their daily rotation. All the other poor little guys in their enormous collection were left to practically suffocate under a thick layer of cobwebs in the corner of the cupboard. Piece by piece we would unload the cupboard and stack the dirty dishware around the kitchen and dining room. We were never allowed to place them on the floor although I truly don't see how that mattered as they were about to be washed anyway, but those were the rules. While my grandmother did own a dishwasher, unfortunately most of the pieces were delicate items that were not dishwasher eligible. Not to mention tossing a few of those dust-enrobed items into the dishwasher might do irreparable harm to the interior components of the appliance. Without dad's expertise to save the day, the dust clogged dishwasher would end up being a total loss, so we were left to wash everything by hand.
My grandmother would park herself at the head of the dining room table to watch the action unfold. My mom was the foreman who oversaw the operation while tending to a myriad of other tasks at the same time. We were like a tiny fire brigade rescuing long lost trivets and teacups from choking to death on dust balls. My brother being the tallest was charged with dish removal, cupboard
We never thought to question why she held onto this massive myriad of dishes, the majority of which, she never even used. Nor did we question why in the world no one broke down and slapped some doors onto this crazy cupboard to cut down on all the mess. We just happily scrubbed and polished and hummed little tunes until the whole job was done. It was a weird little ritual that we knew was completely fruitless. By the time we returned for the winter holidays, our work would be all but undone. We knew this but somehow, we still didn't mind doing it. While we tended to those dusty dishes, my grandmother would fuss at my mother who was scurrying about the house trying to accomplish everything else that had been jotted down onto my grandmother's super lengthy list of spring cleaning chores. My mom would be washing bedspreads, rotating winter and spring wardrobes, wiping down walls, and supervising her dish-washing children, while simultaneously tending to a pile of mending that threatened to topple off of the dining room table and take out one of the dogs at any moment. While all this was happening, my grandmother would be tsk-tsking my mother for allowing her grandchildren to do so much hard work. Oddly enough, she was totally okay with my mom bearing the brunt of the spring cleaning responsibilities, but she felt the children should be spared this kind of intensive labor.
The truth is we didn't mind helping our mom out at Grandma's house, but our motives weren't as virtuous as I've led you to believe. If we weren't there to pitch in, she would have had to leave us at home alone with dad for at least a week while she was away trying to tidy up at her mom's house. Not having mom at home for weeks on end made all of our lives, including Dad's, mostly miserable. Dad did the very best he could while mom was away and there were loads of perks to be enjoyed when dad was at the helm. It always meant that we were allowed to eat as many bowls of sugary cereal as our bellies could hold which sounded great until you came down with the worst tummy ache of your life. We didn't have to take a bath if we didn't feel like it which sounded great until somebody at school told you that you were starting to smell like a farm animal. Bedtime could be drawn out way later than usual which sounded great until you actually had to get up at the same time as usual the next morning in order to catch the schoolbus. Life in our house just wasn't the same without mom.
Dad didn't have all the secret knowledge of those special things that only mom knew how to do. He didn't know how to fold our socks quite right. He couldn't put our hair in French braids. He once got a little carried away with the laundry soap and filled the entire hallway of our house with soap suds. While having a foam party in the hallway of your home might sound like sheer awesomeness, especially since this incident occurred before foam parties were ever a thing, I assure you that the excitement of being on the cutting edge of this kind of entertainment quickly wore off. Repeatedly wading through a wall of soap suds in order to reach your bedroom, while wearing swim goggles to protect your eyes from stinging laundry soap, and trying to breathe through a snorkel so that you didn't end up with the taste of Tide in your mouth was less than ideal. To save mom from weeks of scrubbing at Grandma's house, with the secret plan of getting her to come back home with us at the end of the day, we were willing to do whatever we could to make it happen. I'm not saying dad couldn't handle managing the house, he just couldn't do it like mom, a fact he himself would readily admit if you ask him. Don't worry about my dad's feelings though as he also had a stake in operation bring-mom-home. Despite the fact that he himself was unable to come help with the chores, don't think for a moment that we weren't richly rewarded by Dad (unbeknownst to mom of course) for making sure that mom was back in the car and on the road home with us by nightfall. It's true that our allegiance came cheap in the form of ice cream cones and chocolate bars, but we were handsomely paid off nonetheless.
As for my own kitchen situation, it may take a bit longer than I originally planned, but I am sure that I will eventually be able to replace my two open cupboards. Unfortunately, the ones Dad built will probably never wear out as both the sideboard and the Easter island are far too well made to meet an untimely end. I've really tried hard to abuse them in the hopes that they might crumble, but they easily seem to handle whatever I throw at them. Knives, broken dishes, giant blocks of ice, rotten potatoes, my entire body, are all no match for these sturdy kitchen workhorses. I know it is a lofty goal to set, but I hope that we can eventually complete our kitchen remodel before I am too old to do my own spring cleaning. After all, I wouldn't want my grown son and his family to have to come hose off all the dirty, unloved dishes that have been hanging out on our open kitchen shelving, gathering dust and debris for a whole year. It is also a great incentive to take immediate action by decluttering any of those unused and unloved items that have been languishing on my kitchen shelves since way back when we moved in.
On that note, I'm going to go wipe down the shelves of my open cupboards for the two hundredth time this year and see if I can't rustle up a few more objects of kitchen clutter to donate to the Goodwill Store. Maybe for old time's sake, I'll fill my high efficiency washer with regular old laundry soap to see if I can successfully fill our basement with soap suds in honor of my dad. While my son naps, and I patiently wait to see if out-of-control suds monsters start to climb up the basement stairs, I'm going to sit down and write a letter to those folks at Ikea. As I am sure you might guess, I am recommending the removal of open cupboards from both their catalogues and their store displays. It's the right thing to do, lest some poor unsuspecting newlywed couple blow their budget on a trendy set of open cabinets that I promise they will rapidly regret installing even if they seem like a good idea at the time of purchase.
Unless of course they happen to be the kind of couple who can comfortably afford to hire someone to clean their kitchen for them. Then they can install as many open cupboards as they like because the responsibility of keeping them clean and tidy will fall entirely on someone else. In fact, I am certain that their hired help will be happy to clean every single item on every open shelf in the house as often as they request because the lovely couple is paying them to do just that. I just hope they're not surprised if one day they discover via nanny cam, that the housekeeper has actually been scrubbing their favorite crystal wine glasses in the toilet bowl using the bossman's or bosslady's toothbrush. After all, it doesn't matter to the cleaning person, they're wearing gloves and they don't typically drink wine at the house of their boss, not out of a glass anyway. Why dirty a glass when you can take a swig right from the bottle? And the hired help certainly isn't about to use their employer's toothbrush. Gross, that thing has been in the toilet! Of course, everyone is free to make their own home decorating choices, but when it comes to deciding to place open cupboards in your kitchen, you can't say that no one warned you!